8 Historical Horror Novels You’ll Want to Shove in the Freezer

The Hunger by Alma Katsu

Most of us are familiar with the story of the ill-fated Donner Party, who took their covered wagons west but got caught in a mountain snow storm and had to resort to cannibalism to stay alive. Now imagine the story of the Donner Party, but with a diseased and hungry monster stalking the caravan as they make their way towards the mountains.

The Ballad of Black Tom  by Victor LaValle

Tommy Tester is a hustler just trying to make ends meet in New York City, but when he unknowingly delivers an occult book to a reclusive old woman in Queens, he suddenly finds himself in a hell of a lot more trouble than he originally anticipated. Fans of Lovecraftian horror, this one’s for you.

The Winter People by Jennifer McMahon

1908, West Hall, Vermont: Sara Harrison Shea is found dead in the field behind her house, just months after the death of her daughter. Now flash forward to the present day, when 19-year-old Ruthie, her younger sister, and their mother live in Sara’s old farmhouse. When their mother mysteriously disappears one morning, Ruthie discovers Sara’s diary hidden in their mom’s bedroom and gets sucked into a supernatural historical mystery that hasn’t yet been solved.

Beloved by Toni Morrison

Sethe, who was born a slave, has escaped to Ohio, but her new home is haunted by the horrifying memories of Sweet Home and the ghost of her nameless baby. It’s a ghost story on the surface, but behind the supernatural lies the soul-crushing horrors of American slavery.

Mayhem by Sarah Pinborough

Scotland Yard already has its hands full with trying to capture Jack the Ripper, and now there’s another killer in their midst who has been dubbed the Torso Killer, who neatly wraps his victims’ body parts and steals their heads. Police surgeon Dr. Thomas Bond has taken to scouring London’s opium dens for some much-needed relief, but one evening meets a Jesuit priest in the same opium dens who has some horrifyingly unnatural theories about the Torso Killer.

The Silent Companions by Laura Purcell

Just weeks after marrying the wealthy heir Rupert Bainbridge, Elsie is suddenly a young widow on a large estate, with very few people for company. There’s a painted wooden figure in the house that bears a striking resemblance to Elsie, and although she doesn’t pay it much attention at first, she can’t help notice the way that the figure’s eyes start to follow her…

See What I Have Done by Sarah Schmidt

On August 4, 1892, Andrew and Abby Borden were found brutally murdered in their home by their daughter Lizzie. But for the police, there are more questions than answers, especially since Lizzie’s memories don’t always match up with the reality of the scene in front of them. The horror of this story comes from the brutal imagery, told through fragmented and suspicious memories, and the evocative language that leaves the reader supremely unsettled. You haven’t heard the story of Lizzie Borden told quite like this.

The Terror by Dan Simmons

The men aboard the HMS Terror expected to have a triumphant expedition searching for the Northwest Passage. But after two years stranded in the Arctic Circle, the men find themselves succumbing to the cold, the diminishing rations, and an unseen predator stalking the ship. At nearly 800 pages long, this book is the very definition of a “slow burn,” but it’s well worth the effort.

Want more? Here are a few additional creepy historical novels to keep the scares going.