8 Overrated Literary Classics and 8 Books to Read Instead

Don’t @ me on this one, either. I totally get why and how The Catcher in the Rye became a classic, as well as how influential its main protagonist would become in the popular culture of decades to come. But it doesn’t hold up, and I said what I said. It’s dated. Maybe some teenagers might still see themselves in Holden Caulfield when they read it for the first time, but it’s just nothing all that groundbreaking if you’re going to read it for the first time in 2023.

Declared “The Catcher in the Rye for the digital age” when it was first published, Alice Oseman’s Solitaire is the first book in the “Osemanverse,” if you will, the series that would eventually launch a couple named Nick and Charlie to superstardom by way of a spin-off webcomic turned graphic novel series called Heartstopper. Solitaire follows Charlie’s older sister Tori Spring, an antisocial and depressed teenager who prefers solitude and blogging to interacting with others. Then there’s Michael, the one person who actually wants to spend time with her. But when a suspicious group called Solitaire starts planning dangerous pranks around their school, Tori realizes that sometimes all it takes is one person and one voice to change things.

I was oblivious to the racist passages in Huckleberry Finn growing up, but I can definitely concur now that it, too, is hopelessly dated and better left in the past. Not to mention that it’s not a very constructive book to read about the concepts of childhood or boyhood. Coupled together with the casual racism, it’s probably best to choose something else other than Huckleberry Finn.

Instead of getting dirty and playing cricket with his brother, Arjie prefers to dress up as a girl. Funny Boy chronicles Arjie’s coming of age, from his childhood to his turbulent adolescence, where he battles racism and homophobia at every turn. War in Sri Lanka also begins to affect his family’s comfortable lifestyle, which forces violence and soon tragedy into their lives. Combining political and personal narratives, Funny Boy wants us to consider what happens when we dare to live as our most authentic selves regardless of the odds stacked against us.

The fact that this book is about a grown adult man lusting after a 12-year-old girl should be justification enough for some not to read it, but the general consensus surrounding Lolita’s enduring popularity is that Nabokov’s writing is beautiful; it’s just the premise that’s disturbing. I don’t know about you, but no amount of beautiful prose should be enough to get over a premise as problematic as that of Lolita.

Think of My Last Innocent Year as a type of Lolita told from a modern female point of view. Isabel Rosen is in her last year at Wilder College in New Hampshire when she begins to take a liking to her new creative writing professor, R.H. Connelly. While their ensuing affair is far from non-consensual, as the lives of the adults around her start to fall apart, Isabel begins realizing the power dynamics at play in her relationship with her professor.

I hope I don’t offend anyone who might love this book too much with my frankness: you’ll get the same kind of warm hug from a Hallmark greeting card as you will from Tuesdays with Morrie. Okay, I know by today’s standards, the trope of the old man bestowing his knowledge and wisdom on the younger man is incredibly overdone, and it wasn’t yet when this book was first published. But having been assigned this book in high school, there wasn’t a single life lesson from it that I couldn’t have also learned from an inspirational phrase from a life coach on The Oprah Winfrey Show.

Now this is a classic that should never go out of style. Short, sweet, and full of endless knowledge and wisdom on the creative life, Letters to a Young Poet consists of 10 letters exchanged between Rilke and Franz Xaver Kappus, a cadet officer at a military academy in Vienna. Kappus became a fan of Rilke’s poetry while at military school and decided to write to him for advice on how to become a good poet. Rilke’s responses would become famous since he declined to criticize or comment on Kappus’ work; instead, he advised him to go inward and trust nobody but himself in his pursuit of creativity. The letters were exchanged over a period of years between 1902 and 1908, and Kappus published them in 1929, three years after Rilke’s death.

Little Women does remain a classic in its own right for being a story for women by women, but at the end of the day, there are just so many other female-centric narratives written by women that are worthy of the same amount of attention — not to mention narratives about women by women of color that never would have received the same amount of high praise as Alcott did for Little Women. So it’s not so much that the story itself isn’t great or doesn’t stand the test of time; it’s just time to make room for other women’s stories now.

In Gloria Naylor’s most beloved novel, she brings together the stories of seven Black women living in Brewster Place, an urban sanctuary for the lives and loves of these sisters, bound together by time and space. Considered by many critics to be a contemporary classic of African American literature, The Women of Brewster Place deserve to have a seat at the table just as much as the March sisters do.