Comics/Graphic Novels

My Favorite Golden Age Superman Story

Jessica Plummer

Contributing Editor

Jessica Plummer has lived her whole life in New York City, but she prefers to think of it as Metropolis. Her day job is in books, her side hustle is in books, and she writes books on the side (including a short story in Sword Stone Table from Vintage). She loves running, knitting, and thinking about superheroes, and knows an unnecessary amount of things about Donald Duck. Follow her on Twitter at @jess_plummer.

Despite being the oldest and one of the most beloved superheroes of all time, Superman has a reputation today for being difficult to write. He’s both incredibly powerful and unflaggingly good, which often leaves modern writers a bit stumped, and has led to a succession of truly depressing Superman movies.

Golden Age writers, however, understood that the secret is not throwing ever bigger threats at Superman, giving him a mullet, or making him a stalker and/or murderer. No, the secret is simple: put him in absolutely ludicrous workplace romcom scenarios. My favorite comes in Superman #20 (February 1943), written by Superman creator Jerry Siegel and drawn by Ed Dobrotka.

The story, “Superman’s Secret Revealed!” begins with Clark Kent and Lois Lane leaving “a swanky restaurant” after lunch, but when he asks the hat-check girl for his hat, she presents him with a Superman costume instead:

Three panels from Superman #20.

Panel 1: The hat-check girl holds up a newspaper to show Clark, while Lois watches.

Hat-Check Girl: And don't bother to deny it. This article in the Daily Planet by Miss Lane tells the whole sensational story.
Clark: Article? - Let me see that!

Panel 2: Clark reads the article, with the headline of "Clark Kent Really Superman." He is so shocked an exclamation mark appears over his head.

Panel 3: Clark stares at the newspaper as a collage of images of him as Superman, fighting villains and saving Lois, appears behind his head.

Clark, thinking: This...this is too much of a shock! After all these years of going to great lengths to conceal my true identity, it's actually out!"

Clark is naturally stunned that his secret has gotten out, but then Lois laughs and explains that it was all a prank: she had Carl, the head pressman at the Daily Planet, print up a few fake newspapers as a gag. Little does she know, though, that while she and Clark were at lunch, Carl was struck with appendicitis…meaning that the rest of the printing team assumed the fake edition was the real edition, and printed hundreds of thousands of copies of Lois’s “expose.” A wire service picked up the story, and now the whole world knows that Clark Kent is Superman. WHOOPS.

Back at the office, editor Perry White is furious that Lois’s joke has ruined the Planet’s reputation, and Clark of course is none too pleased either, although not for the reason Perry and Lois think. Lois, for her part, refuses to acknowledge that she has done anything wrong even though she super duper has. I love her.

Luckily, Clark has a solution:

Three panels from Superman #20.

Panel 1: Perry's office. Perry is standing behind his desk and Clark and Lois are in front of it.

Perry: Young woman - do you realize what you've done? This has been a respectable newspaper for 150 years...and now you've ruined our reputation for reliability!
Clark: Whatever you do, don't blame me. I'm the victim of a practical joke!
Lois: And what are you so excited about? You should feel honored that people think you are Superman!

Panel 2: All three continue to argue.

Lois: If this newspaper is so stuffy it can't take a little joke, then I don't care to work for it any longer.
Perry: You don't care to work for it? Why, I'll have you...
Clark: Stop arguing! Listen to me!
Clark (thinking): I don't want Lois to lose her job...and I've got to do something to clean up this mess!

Panel 3: A closeup of Clark.

Clark: Come to think of it, there's nothing so terrible about a newspaper perpetrating a joke on its readers. Remember "The Great Balloon Hoax?" A leading newspaper proclaimed someone had flown to the moon. The public ate it up, and when it was revealed it had all been a joke, the country took it good-naturedly!

Clark appears to be conflating two separate hoaxes here: “The Great Moon Hoax,” a series of six articles claiming to have discovered a civilization on the moon, and “The Balloon-Hoax,” a single article describing a trip across the Atlantic Ocean in a hot air balloon. Both stories were published by The Sun in New York.

Except, uh…”The Great Moon Hoax” was published in 1835, and “The Balloon-Hoax” in 1844 (it was written by Edgar Allen Poe!). Clark, honey, I feel like “people were okay with this a hundred years ago so it should be fine now” is not the solid argument you think it is.

Either way, Lois and Perry think it’s a great idea, and immediately bully Clark into a Superman costume:

Two panels from Superman #20.

Panel 1: Lois and Perry push Clark, who is holding a Superman costume, through an open door.

Clark: Excellent, nothing! I won't do it!
Lois: Oh, yes you will!
Perry: Change in the next room. That's an order!

Panel 2: Clark has changed into the Superman costume, but is still wearing his glasses.

Clark: So Clark Kent is to impersonate Superman! This has possibilities!

Look. This is not a good working environment. If your boss makes you put on a Superman costume in order to lie to the public, remember that we are in the Great Resignation, and quit like the wind.

But I love screwball comedy and this is such good screwball comedy. When will adaptations of Superman understand this energy? (I mean, the answer to that is “In 1993, specifically Lois & Clark: The New Adventures of Superman,” but I need more.)

Six panels from Superman #20.

Panel 1: An outside view of the Daily Planet building. Lois leans out of a window on the top floor (the 7th), while Clark clings to the window ledge a bit further along the building.

Lois: Clark! Careful!
Clark (thinking): Lois tried to play a joke on me. Here's where I get even!

Panel 2: Clark stands on the ledge unsteadily while Lois points down.

Clark: I - I'm getting dizzy...I'm afraid I'm going to fall!
Lois: Don't look towards the street! It makes you dizzy!

Panel 3: Clark teeters backwards precariously.

Clark: H-H-H-HALP!!

Panel 4: A closeup of Lois covering her eyes.

Lois: He fell!

Panel 5: A view from inside the office. Clark pops up at the window with a pigeon on his head.

Clark: No, I didn't! And I wish this doggone pigeon would find some other place to alight!
Lois: Here comes White! Hang on! He'll help you!

Panel 6: Perry and Lois help Clark inside.

Perry: Don't scare us like that again!
Clark: YOU'RE scared??!
Lois: After this ordeal, I think you'd better take the day off. I'll escort you home.
The fact that he went and found a pigeon to put on his head like a prop really makes this page. Zach Snyder could never.

Naturally, the shenanigans escalate, with Lois demanding that Perry and a supposedly terrified Clark crawl out onto the window ledge to stage some Supermannish stunts. Clark decides to get a little bit of his own back by pretending to fall, which shocks Perry and Lois into deciding he should lay low until the hoax is exposed.

One panel from Superman #20. A huge crowd has gathered outside of the Daily Planet and Clark (in the Superman costume) and Lois are trying to push through to a waiting cab. In the foreground are a man and a boy, clearly Bruce Wayne and Dick Grayson from the dialogue.

Narration Box: But as the two emerge from the newspaper building...
Person #1: I want you to appear on the Tantamount Theater stage for three weeks!
Person #2: Sign this contract and your fortune is made!
Person #3: Endorse my breakfast food and you can retire tomorrow! Lead a life of ease and let your imitators do the crook-chasing for you!
Person #4: If I could just get his cloak for a souvenir...!
Bruce: To think he even had ME fooled!
Dick: And it's no cinch to fool the Batman!
Clark: Please let us thru!

Easier said than done, because a crowd has gathered outside, complete with a then-exceedingly rare cameo by Batman and Robin. This is actually a huge deal, since at this point Superman and Batman had never officially met. They appeared on many covers together, but never interacted in the actual stories. They wouldn’t meet for real until Superman #79 in 1952 (it’s a “there was only one bed” story, YES REALLY), so this little Easter egg is a significant piece of comics history if you are a huge continuity nerd, which I obviously am.

Suddenly, someone starts shooting at “Superman,” reminding Clark that this stunt is dangerous. (Lois continues to refuse to admit it’s a bad idea. I LOVE HER.) Meanwhile, Perry decides to up the ante by calling a bank president friend of his bank and talking him into staging a holdup that will be thwarted by “Superman.” This is overheard by some gangsters who have coincidentally snuck into the Planet offices for murder reasons. Of course it is.

Clark is pressured into participating in this truly terrible farce, but unbeknownst to all of our heroes, the real gangsters, knowing “Superman” is a fake, kidnap the actors who have been hired for the staged robbery and take their place. They hold up the bank for real and attempt to kill “Superman” — but Clark, of course, just pretends to have been replaced by the “real” Superman, and easily thwarts the gangsters before leaving and returning as “fake” Superman.

But one of the gangsters is determined to at least kill Lois, because why not. He shoots at her, and Clark throws himself in front of the bullet:

Six panels from Superman #20.

Panel 1: A security guard punches out the gangster while Lois cradles a prone Clark, in his glasses and the Superman costume.

Guard: You'll get the chair for this!
Lois: Oh, Clark! You shouldn't have done it!

Panel 2: Perry comforts a crying Lois.

Perry: There's nothing more you can do.
Lois: Yes there is. I can always blame myself - for the rest of my life - for his death!

Panel 3: A closeup of Lois crying.

Lois: I never realized, until he was gone, how fine a person he was! Kind, generous - and I - I brought about his destruction!

Panel 4: Clark sits up, smiling, to Lois's shock.

Clark: Gee, Lois! I never dreamed you cared!
Lois: Clark! Alive!!

Panel 5: Clark explains.

Lois: But - but I saw "Ironjaw" shoot you!
Clark: Since Superman's underworld enemies started shooting at me, I decided to go nowhere without a bullet-proof vest beneath the costume. That's what saved my life!

Panel 6: Lois slaps Clark.

Lois: Then you were laughing at me all the time!
Clark: People who play practical jokes should expect some in return.

And there it is: a perfect screwball ending. Yes, the slap is a dated trope that I’m glad we’ve left in the past, but can’t you see Rosalind Russell and Cary Grant acting out all of these scenes? I can, and it’s a beautiful dream.

There are plenty of other Golden Age Superman stories that steer into these delightful hijinks, and like I said, Lois & Clark was very much in this vein as well. I am holding out hope that the upcoming My Adventures with Superman will have a similar energy — everything I’ve heard about the show so far has been encouraging!

In the meantime, we’ll always have 1943.