In the Club

Book Club Books at the Biggest Public Libraries

This content contains affiliate links. When you buy through these links, we may earn an affiliate commission.

Erica Ezeifedi

Associate Editor

Erica Ezeifedi, Associate Editor, is a transplant from Nashville, TN that has settled in the North East. In addition to being a writer, she has worked as a victim advocate and in public libraries, where she has focused on creating safe spaces for queer teens, mentorship, and providing test prep instruction free to students. Outside of work, much of her free time is spent looking for her next great read and planning her next snack. Find her on Twitter at @Erica_Eze_.

This month, I thought to look at what the biggest libraries in the country were reading in their book clubs. The ALA, where I got my library size information, categorizes “big” for libraries in a few different ways—there are categorizations by circulation, holdings, or library visits. I chose to look at the size of the population plus the collection expenditures. I think this statistic has the added bonus of letting us know a little more about the community that the library is nestled in.

Below are the three biggest libraries in the US and what they read in one of their book clubs this month. The books include thee book of 2024, a mystery with a 20-year-old case, and a meditation on the granularity of relationship dynamics and identity.

Maricopa County Library District (AZ)- Population: 4,367,835

cover of James by Percival Everett

James by Percival Everett

From the author of Erasure comes a retelling of The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn, but from Jim’s point of view. Jim is an enslaved man who learns he’s about to be sold to a white man in New Orleans, and so hides out until he can think of something that’ll keep him from being separated from his family. Then he meets Huck Finn — running from his own problems — and the two embark on their familiar story, this time with Jim’s full humanity on display.

Los Angeles Public Library (CA)- Population: 4,040,079

cover of The Return of Ellie Black by Emiko Jean; black with outline of dead flower inside orange outline of a woman

The Return of Ellie Black by Emiko Jean

Twenty years ago, Detective Chelsey Clahoun’s sister disappeared. Her sister was never seen again, so Chelsey dedicated her life to finding other missing girls, which is a pretty depressing vocation, not going to lie. Turns out people are awful, and Chelsey’s cases rarely end nicely, but then a teenager who’d been missing for two years — Ellie Black — turns up alive in the woods. The happy turn of events turns sour, though, when Chelsey realizes that Ellie is not trying to spill on what happened, who took her, or where she’s been all this time, and Chelsey will need to know all those things if she’s to stop another girl from being taken.

New York Public Library (NY)- Population: 3,439,711

audition book cover

Audition by Katie Kitamura

Here, an accomplished actress and an attractive younger man meet for lunch in a Manhattan restaurant. Who they are to each other is a question that Kitamura’s narrative unfurls, except it extends the question to all relationships. It looks at the dynamics—or roles—we have with different people in our lives, showing how we’re constantly auditioning, even with people who think they know us best.

Suggestion Section

Book Club Tings:

A printable list of book club-friendly questions

More To Read

BRIDGERTON Season 4 is Coming in 2026 — Here’s Everything We Know

I’m With the Sand: 5 of the Best SFF Beach Reads

NYT: 31 Novels Coming This Summer

**Below is a list of book club-friendly books for All Access members**

Erica Ezeifedi

Associate Editor

Erica Ezeifedi, Associate Editor, is a transplant from Nashville, TN that has settled in the North East. In addition to being a writer, she has worked as a victim advocate and in public libraries, where she has focused on creating safe spaces for queer teens, mentorship, and providing test prep instruction free to students. Outside of work, much of her free time is spent looking for her next great read and planning her next snack. Find her on Twitter at @Erica_Eze_.

The Grimoire Grammar School Parent Teacher Association by Caitlin Rozakis- Fantasy

cover of Along Came Amor by Alexis Daria

Along Came Amor by Alexis Daria- Romance

When Sally Killed Harry by Lucy Roth- Mystery/Thriller

The Busybody Book Club by Freya Sampson

Dreaming of Home: How We Turn Fear into Pride, Power, and Real Change by Cristina Jiménez- Memoir,

The South by Tash Aw- Fiction

Forest Euphoria: The Abounding Queerness of Nature by Patricia Ononiwu Kaishian- Nature, Nonfiction

Soft as Bones: A Memoir by Chyana Marie Sage- Memoir

Join All Access to read this article

Get access to exclusive content and features with an All Access subscription on Book Riot.

  • Unlimited access to exclusive bonus content
  • Community features like commenting and poll participation
  • Our gratitude for supporting the work of an independent media company

For more book club goodness, click here.