Riot Headline 10 Exciting Books to Read this Summer
Our Reading Lives

Best of Book Riot: Analyzing the Library Hold List

Kim Ukura

Staff Writer

Kim Ukura is a book lover, recovering journalist, library advocate, cat mom, and lover of a good gin cocktail. In addition to co-hosting Book Riot’s nonfiction podcast, For Real, and co-editing Book Riot’s nonfiction newsletter, True Story, Kim spends her days working in communications at a county library system in the Twin Cities area. Kim has a BA in English and journalism from a small liberal arts college in Minnesota, and a master’s in journalism from the University of Wisconsin, Madison. When not getting to bed before 10 p.m., Kim loves to read nonfiction, do needlework projects, drink tea, and watch the Great British Baking Show. Instagram: @kimthedork Twitter: @kimthedork

To celebrate the end of the year, we’re running some of our favorite posts from the last six months. We’ll be back with all-new stuff on January 7th.

Earlier this week I had what is, I think, one of the best experiences for a book nerd: picking up a long-anticipated hold at my local library.

The book in question was Gillian Flynn’s Gone Girl, arguably the buzziest book of the summer. When I got the email notification that the book had finally arrived, I squeed to a friend online and told her that I had been waiting FOREVER to get the book. Then I went to check my library website and discovered I’d actually had a request in for the book since June 17, only about 50 days.

I live in rural Minnesota and am part of a small library system where holds that long are rare, so I suppose I can be forgiven for thinking it was an eternity. When I lived in a bigger city, Madison, Wisconsin, it wasn’t uncommon to wait on a hold list for several months for a popular book.

Because I’m a book nerd who also loves playing with numbers (even if I’m terrible at it), I decided to compare my small, local library system to some other cities to see how much longer I might be waiting for Gone Girl if I lived somewhere else.

To figure it out I collected a few different stats on some different library systems: the number of copies of Gone Girl at each libary, the number of current holds for the book, and the total population the library (or library system) serves. I then used those numbers to calculate the number of holds for each book available and the population of patrons for each book in the system, hoping those numbers would tell me something. Here’s what I found:

My Library: The Viking Library System

An 11-library system serving 6 counties in rural Minnesota

  • Copies of Gone Girl: 14
  • Current Holds: 59
  • Population: 123,609
  • Holds/Book: 4.2
  • Population/Book: 8,829

Madison Public Library (South Central Library System)
A 52-library system serving seven counties in Wisconsin

  • Copies of Gone Girl: 113
  • Current Holds: 1,151
  • Population: 5,200,381
  • Holds/Book: 10.2
  • Population/Book: 46,021

    Hennepin County Library
    A 41-library system serving Minneapolis, Minnesota

    • Copies of Gone Girl: 145
    • Current Holds: 1,588
    • Population: 1,152,425
    • Holds/Book: 10.9
    • Population/Book: 7,948

    New York Public Library
    An 87-library system serving the Bronx, Manhattan and Staten Island

    • Copies of Gone Girl: 288
    • Current Holds: 2,020
    • Cardholders: 2,215,157
    • Population: 3,464,417
    • Holds/Book: 7.0
    • Population/Book: 12,029

    Unfortunately, the more I collected and made calculations, the less sure I became about whether these numbers could tell me anything. Most significantly, the number of holds per book in my current library system (4.2) is much lower than the systems I compared it too, at least one indication of why I moved up the hold list so quickly.

    My library also has a comparable number of books per population as two of the other libraries, which could indicate these libraries had a pretty similar idea of how popular Gone Girl might be. However, that’s also a difficult metric, since it not all libraries can afford to buy so many copies of a single book. It also doesn’t include available ebooks or audiobooks, which other libraries may have more of than my library system

    But as a couple of friends pointed out, every library system is a little different, and those differences matter. Shorter or longer loan periods, differences in how books are transferred between libraries, and the number of people in the population who have a library card would all make a difference. And a different book would almost certainly show different numbers. So I guess this little exercise wasn’t especially conclusive, but I thought it was fun.

    How does your library hold system work? How long do you have to wait for popular books? What’s the longest hold list you’ve ever seen? At what point do you give up on the library and just buy a copy of the book yourself?