5 Diverse Romances We Want to See as Hallmark Christmas Movies

Every year at around this time, an onslaught of feel-good movies seem to be perpetually airing on the Hallmark Channel (and its sister channel, Hallmark Movies & Mysteries). These movies stick rigidly to a now-familiar formula in which snowball fights, sipping hot chocolate while strolling down a picturesque street, and almost-but-not-actually kissing are fundamental steps toward falling in love. As these movies become more and more popular, and the channel produces more and more of them, increased scrutiny has fallen on just how white, cis, and straight the casts of Hallmark Christmas movies tend to be.

Last year saw their first film with non-white leads. This year, two films look to incorporate Hanukkah into the otherwise Christmas-centric film universe. Still, there is still a ways to go for Hallmark Christmas movies to better reflect cultural diversity. Luckily, these romance novels with at least one POC lead character are right there just waiting to be adapted into Hallmark Christmas movies!

Holiday by Candlelight by Laurel Greer

Dr. Caleb Matsuda had to switch from surgery to being a family doctor, following a traumatizing skiing accident. Between his PTSD and feeling like an outsider in a small Montana town, holiday cheer is low on his priority list. But the lively search-and-rescue volunteer Garnet James may be just who he needs to deal with these issues as they’re thrown together for Hanukkah, Christmas, and New Year’s.

Their Festive Island Escape by Nina Singh

Celeste Frajedi should have been a Christmas bride three years ago…except she got jilted at the altar. This year, she heads to Jamaica for a sun-filled holiday at a luxury resort. Just her luck that the resort’s CEO is Reid Evanson, the would-be best man at her non-wedding. Can these two put their past behind them? And might their will they/won’t they chemistry mean he’s the one to restore her love of the festive season?

Royal Holiday by Jasmine Guillory

Vivian Forest accompanies her stylist daughter on a trip to England. She’d expected to spend her holiday sight-seeing, but is surprised to find herself falling for Malcolm Hudson, the Queen’s private secretary. Will their steamy affair end by New Year’s, or can this unexpected romance see them beyond the holiday season?

This Christmas Rivalry by Beverly Jenkins

An enemies-to-lovers holiday story with a sporty twist! Tasha Bloom, the granddaughter of a football team’s owner, is surprised to unexpectedly inherit the team…especially since Drew Davis, the general manager, had been planning to buy it first. Sparks fly as Tasha and Drew’s passion for football turns into passion for each other. But can the team and their budding romance make it to the New Year’s Day championship?

Hanukkah at the Great Greenwich Ice Creamery by Sharon Ibbotson

Cohen Ford is the kind of guy who walks into an ice cream shop…and orders a black coffee. But something about the shop’s owner, River de Luca, intrigues him…and soon he’s visiting her and the shop every week. The more they learn about each other, the more they begin to change in positive ways. Could River be the one to finally help Cohen find a way to embraces Christmas, Hanukkah…and strawberry ice cream?


Looking for more diversity in your holiday romances? Check out these 5 Lesbian and Gay Holiday Romances. And if you can’t get enough Hallmark Christmas movies, try this tongue-in-cheek post on How To Write A Hallmark Romance.

Ann Foster @http://twitter.com/@annfosterwriter

Ann can often be found walking very slowly through the aisles of bookstores, making sure that nothing new has come out she doesn’t know about yet, and then eagerly telling people about them. She writes about women from history at annfosterwriter.com, and about books, film, TV, and feminism at various other sites. She prefers her books to include at least three excellent plot twists, which is why she usually reads the end first. Twitter: @annfosterwriter

Recent Posts

Book Riot’s Deals of the Day for December 10th, 2019

The best book deals of the day, curated by Book Riot.

15 hours ago

Living History: 5 Comics About History and Culture

Next time you or the kids are looking for an informative nonfiction or historical fiction read, pick up one of…

19 hours ago

Be Brave: 4 Middle Grade Novels About Standing Up for Yourself

Show the kids positive representations of characters standing up for what they believe in with these middle grade books about…

19 hours ago

Books About Roller Derby for the Armchair Derbyist

Maybe you participate, maybe you're thinking about joining a team, maybe you just want to read about it--here are some…

19 hours ago

6 of the Best Sick Day Reads

Down for the count thanks to cold and flu season? We got you with a few sick day books that'll…

19 hours ago

THE WINDS OF WINTER Release Date: Everything We Know (For Now)

THE WINDS OF WINTER release date is coming — maybe? What we know and don't know about George R.R. Martin's…

19 hours ago