Review GPA: RIN TIN TIN: THE LIFE, THE LEGEND by Susan Orlean

In Review GPA, we translate reviews of notable new books into letter grades and determine a grade point average. Check out previous report cards of ZONE ONE and THE MARRIAGE PLOT.

__________________________

From The New Republic review by David Thomson

Gold Star:

“This dog’s eye history of Hollywood in the 1920s is exuberant and told with as much energy as love.”

Demerit:

“But at the end, in a chapter called ‘The Leap,’ she goes a little far, I think. She feels compelled to see her story as an example of love, heroes, bonding, and all good things.”

Grade: A-

__________________________

From The New York Times review by Jennifer Schuessler

Gold Star:

“Do dogs deserve biographies? In “Rin Tin Tin: The Life and the Legend,” Susan Orlean answers that question resoundingly in the affirmative”

Demerit:

“Orlean wants to see the Rin Tin Tin obsessives she meets mainly as dreamers looking for some lost wholeness rather than hangers-on with a stake in a valuable piece of intellectual property.”

Grade: A-

__________________________

From the Kirkus review:

Gold Star…and Demerit:

“Although occasionally excessive in its claims for the ultimate significance of it all, a terrific dog’s tale that will make readers sit up and beg for more.”

Grade: A-

__________________________

From The Washington Post review by Jonathan Yardley

Gold Star:

“It’s a touching and revealing story, not merely on its own merits but because it parallels the changing place of dogs in American life, from outdoor workers to indoor pets.”

Demerit:

“She has, as I noted two decades ago while reviewing her book about Saturday nights in America, a talent for choosing interesting subjects but then making them far less interesting by using ‘the first-person singular to grating excess.’ Over the years this tendency has, if anything, gotten worse.”

Grade: C+

__________________________

From the Barnes and Noble review by Melissa H. Pierson

Gold Star:

“Neither heavy nor scholarly but trustworthy and true, she makes us want to follow wherever she leads.”

Demerit:

“Susan Orlean can be forgiven for repeating her central thesis a few times too many”

Grade: A

__________________________

Review GPA: 3.48 (B+/A-)

Sign up to get news and book recommendations from the worlds of mysteries and thrillers with the Unusual Suspects newsletter.
Do you like podcasts like This American Life, RadioLab, or Planet Money? Annotated is kinda like those, but for books. Go here to find out more, or click the image below:
VIEW COMMENTS