Review GPA: ZONE ONE by Colson Whitehead

In Review GPA, we translate reviews of notable new books into letter grades and determine a grade point average. Check out last week’s installment on The Marriage Plot by Jeffrey Eugenides.

__________________________

From the Esquire review by Tom Chiarella:

Gold Star:

Zone One marks the arrival of Whitehead’s real narrative engine. He’s telling a story — tumble down, mired in the wreckage of the world we currently pretend to cherish. It’s a book you want to read rather than one you should read.

Demerit: None

Grade: A

__________________________

From the Guardian review by Patrick Ness

Gold Star:

“A fragile hope permeates these pages, one so painful and tender, it’s heartbreaking. There have been sharper zombie tales – the bitter satirical punch of George A Romero’s original Night of the Living Dead film is unimprovable – but I can’t recall one this sad and moving.”

Demerit:

“Whitehead does have a tendency to overwrite – sentences sometimes grow so rhythmical, you fail to take in their actual meaning as the words wash over you…”

Grade: A-

__________________________

From the Entertainment Weekly review by Rob Brunner

Gold Star:

Zone One is not the work of a serious novelist slumming it with some genre-novel cash-in, but rather a lovely piece of writing that happens to be about hordes of homicidal undead.

Demerit:

None

Grade: A-
(publication assigned)

__________________________

From The Wall Street Journal review by James Kennedy:

Gold Star:

“But if you’re going to break down and read a zombie novel, make it this one. Among the hundreds of hamburgers, “Zone One” stands out as the steak. Or better yet, ‘a good, fully developed veal.'”

Demerit:

“…if Mr. Whitehead scents the opportunity to digress on sitcom-inspired hairstyles or the rituals of the human-resources department, he’s not shy about hitting pause on a life-or-death hand-to-hand combat scene. Repeatedly.”

Grade: B+

__________________________

From the Amazon review by Justin Cronin:

Gold Star:

“For a long time Whitehead has strutted his stuff as one of our smartest young writers, and Zone One is every inch the book he was born to write, a pop-culture thriller of the first order. It will make you think.”

Demerit:

None

Grade: A

__________________________

Review GPA: 3.74 (A-)

Sign up to get news and book recommendations from the worlds of mysteries and thrillers with the Unusual Suspects newsletter.
We have 10 copies of our bookish conversation game Lit Chat to give away. Go here to enter for your chance to win, or just click the banner below. Good luck!
VIEW COMMENTS