I was a weird one—I came into Harry Potter fanfiction later in my life. While everyone was digging into fanfiction.net and Sugar Quills getting their Harry fix, I was still reading Canon Only Pride and Prejudice stories, and then, between 2008 and 2010, Anything But Canon Twilight fics. After a bit of hopping through fanfiction for the Marvel Cinematic Universe and James Bond (00Q 4 Lyfe!), I found myself suddenly immersed in the world of Harry James Potter—sometimes with very little of the boy himself.
Not sure what kind of fanfiction reader you are? Here’s a sampling of different types of story, including canon, alternate universe, and pre- and post-canon. Warning: as hinted at in my fanfiction preferences, hate-to-love stories are my favorite, so there’s a lot of Draco Malfoy in these suggestions. Also, most of these are going to be rated M, so check before you give suggestions to your 12 year old relatives. It should also be noted that these are obviously not going to be objective choices and Your Mileage May Vary.
Hermione, Queen of Witches is an Old School fic from the active days of Sugar Quills. In five books, the alternatively titled Secret Diary of Hermione Granger tells the story from Hermione’s point of view in the form of a diary.
After the End is another Old School fic, completed in 2003. Since it was finished before Order of the Phoenix, it feels very nostalgic to read a hopeful, canon-ish story about the Wizarding World. For something written after Deathly Hallows was released, try Rebuilding, which involves Hermione and Draco (among others) returning to Hogwarts after the war for varying reasons.
For The Feels
Tumblr is a hard place to find stories because it’s not searchable the way that ffnet and AO3 are. But when you do come across a beautifully thought out and fleshed out one-shot “what if” story about a family that might have been, you make sure everyone you know reads it. Man. The feels.
The Hermione Granger Can Do Anything Story
Even be sorted into Slytherin. Think that can’t possibly be a thing? You should read The Green Girl, and see how well the author takes that familiar Granger personality and puts it into this very extenuating circumstance.
That One Dramione Story That Everyone Has Read
When you ask anyone who’s been in fandom recently about Dramione, even if they don’t read it, they probably know about Isolation by Bex-Chan. Nominated for a bunch of fanfiction awards when it came out, this story is long and hard and somehow sweet. How can it be sweet when one of the main characters is a bigoted asshole? Well, read it and find out.
The real Carry On
Okay, so not really (no vampires in this one), but if you want to read a Draco-Slash-Harry fic set in an AU Seventh Year in which two boys accidentally end up married after arguing in a doorway, you’ll want to read Bond.
If I Had Made A Different Choice
What’s better than an Epilogue-compliant story that goes awry? An Epilogue-compliant story that goes awry by creating an Alternate Past. Turn sees Harry living a not-quite-HEA with Ginny and the Kids, and after a surprising evening, waking up to see what one different choice might have changed.
The Head Boy/Head Girl Roommates Trope
In this particular story, not only do Hermione and Draco have to share a common room as school Heads, but here, our buddy Draco has Amnesia. Two tropes in one!
Hogwarts Is Over And The World Is Terrible
Better Off Forgotten is some serious darkfic with some serious dubcon (what with the whole, “she’s been obliviated and I’m going to pretend to be someone else because I can’t procreate with purebloods” thing). If that sounds like your thing, have at it.
“Epilogue? What Epilogue” (EWE) (AKA For The Person Who Wants To Wipe Cursed Child From Their Brain)
The Politician’s Wife holds a special place in my heart as one of the first Wizarding World fics I read in which the main characters were no longer teenagers. Started before the release of Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, this story jumps more than twenty years after Hogwarts, to a future in which Draco Malfoy and Hermione Weasley (though he refuses to call her anything but Granger) work for the Ministry of Magic.
The Quintessential Marauders Era
Chronicling the correspondence and adventures of Messrs. Moony, Wormtail, Padfoot and Prongs, The Shoebox Project has had a huge following for over a decade, resulting in extensive amounts of fan art and even spinoff stories.
The Marauders Era But Not Those Dudes
If I had a voice I would sing is the story of Narcissa Black and Lily Evans back in Hogwarts. Warning: it’s a WIP. Who knows how long you might have to wait for any kind of resolution, however sad it will be.
Save The Romance, Just Give Me An Awesome Side Character
Desk Duty is a one shot with a special place in my heart. Join Madam Pince in Year Five as she is visited by the High Inquisitioner. As a librarian, I am all about this little story.
Every Fanfiction Trope Is Happening And I Don’t Know What’s Going On
Seekers Of Love. Dude. Seriously. All The Tropes. (And All The Tags, too! I love AO3 tags!) NotDead!Cedric. Soulmates. OT3. Black Hermione. Half-Desi Harry. All of it. Also a WIP, but is pretty regularly updated.
Bonus: A Rabbit Hole To Start In
I can’t pick one thing so here, have all of the stories in Archive Of Our Own that are tagged Black Hermione Granger. (I will point out that while some of these began long before Noma Dumezweni was cast as Hermione in Harry Potter and the Cursed Child, having her to use as inspiration definitely helped kick these up a notch. Still, racebent characters—and even stories featuring the canon characters of color—are few and far between in the already-very-white fandom that features well over a million fanworks.) Here, there’s art; there are canon-based stories and stories that feature queer and neurodiverse characters. Pick something and start reading.
You never know what stories you might encounter that could just disappear if, say, the author moves to traditional publishing. Once upon a time, there was a trilogy of epic proportions called The Draco Trilogy (that I won’t link because the author technically wants it to not exist on the internet) that ended in a Draco/Ginny pairing. Snappy redhead and an angry blonde in a secret battle to save Mundanes…I mean Muggles…from the megalomadman who wants to rule the world. Hmm. Sounds familiar.
On fanfiction.net alone, there are over seven hundred thousand individual Harry Potter stories. On Archive Of Our Own, there are over 100K more (though some of them are crossposted). You can go on Wattpad or Tumblr to see even more. If there’s a pairing you want to read about, I’ll bet it exists. If you want to read something that doesn’t have a romantic pairing, you can find that too. If these aren’t doing it for you, you’ve got a very deep rabbit hole to dive into.
Have fun! Good luck!