Crossover Appeal #8

Crossover Appeal is a weekly feature that challenges the idea that you have to choose a side between YA and adult fiction. Each week we’ll feature a book that has been marketed as YA and a book that has been marketed as adult and tell you why everyone should be reading them, no matter what happens to be your comfort zone.


YA Books for Adult Lit Readers

When You Reach Me by Rebecca Stead

Miranda, a smart, independent 12-year-old, lives in New York with her mother. She and her best friend Sal know everything there is to know about their neighborhood. Life is ordinary for Miranda, until she begins receiving strange letters about events that haven’t happened yet and Sal stops talking to her at all. The first mysterious note says: I am coming to save your friend’s life, and my own. I must ask two favors: first you must write me a letter. So begins Rebecca Stead’s fabulous When You Reach Me.

Why You’ll Love It

If you’re anything like me, you grew up with A Wrinkle in Time and the rest of Madeleine L’Engle’s novels. When You Reach Me is a novel that evokes the magic of A Wrinkle in Time while still standing on its own as an original story for readers of all ages. I completely fell in love with Miranda and her story and I think you will too, especially if you loved A Wrinkle in Time as much as I did. If you aren’t an avid reader of Young Adult, you probably haven’t ventured into the Middle Grade section of your library or bookstore either, but you’re missing out! There are some seriously beautiful, well-written books that are sold as Middle Grade fiction and When You Reach Me is my favorite place to start.

Adult Lit Books for YA Lit Readers

The Kitchen Daughter by Jael McHenry

When her parents suddenly die, Ginny Selvaggio must endure a lot that she usually avoids: strong feelings of grief, an overbearing sister, a crowd of people at her parents’ funeral that make her extremely uncomfortable. The only thing that seems to make her feel better is cooking, but when she begins cooking old family recipes, something strange happens. As soon as the smells of her Nonna’s soup fill the kitchen, Nonna appears. She quickly disappears, but not before she cryptically warns Ginny to “not let her….” Ginny’s mysterious power is confusing, but so are her relationships with people she always thought she knew and understood. Ginny soon learns how fast everything can change.

Why You’ll Love It

I loved Jael McHenry’s debut The Kitchen Daughter and I think if you’re a fan of When You Reach Me orMarcelo in the Real World, a novel previously featured on Crossover Appeal, you’ll love The Kitchen Daughter. Though it is never directly named, Ginny shows traditional signs of Asperger’s and she is a refreshing main character. I think McHenry did a beautiful job portraying it and also maintained the supernatural elements of the story without it getting cheesy, well at least most of the time. The descriptions of cooking and food are brilliant and the relationships in this novel are spot-on. If you’re not careful, your descriptions of this novel could veer into the supernatural romance category, but The Kitchen Daughter surpasses all the tropes of this saturated genre to be a touching story of love and family.


Leslie Fannon is a blogger, crocheter, graduate student and, most recently, an assistant at a publishing company. She writes about poetry, graphic novels, and Spanish literature at Regular Rumination. Follow her on Twitter: @lulu_bella

The new YA Book Mail box is here, and things are getting a little strange....Get yours now while supplies last! BookMail_YA_RC